Weather

What is the Cost of Lost Solar Production Due to a Major Hailstorm?

On May 2, 2024, a hailstorm with 50–60 mm hail crossed the Anson 1 solar plant near Abilene, Texas, causing severe damage and requiring over 12,000 modules to be remediated [1]. From May–December 2024, the 200 MW site produced about 55% less energy than in the same months of other years. Using data available via the EnergyStream API, we estimate lost energy due to the storm at 194–253 GWh, worth roughly $4.0–5.3 million.

Visualizing the Storm

Around 6:00 PM local time on May 2, 2024, a hailstorm with approximately 50–60 mm hail stones crossed over the Anson 1 solar site near Abilene, TX. The interactive map below shows the path of the hail swath as it moved, with the outline of the Anson site highlighted. The hail data shown here is derived directly from NOAA's MRMS Mesh product.

Hail swath over the site · May 2–3, 2024
NOAA MRMS MESH, 30-min scans
no hail at site
Figure 1: May 2, 2024 hail swath (NOAA MRMS MESH) moving over the Anson 1 site. Basemap is real NAIP aerial imagery of the site (2022, USDA/Microsoft Planetary Computer) — the panel rows are visible directly. Shaded regions are NOAA-estimated hail size buckets for that 30-minute scan, blue (mild) through maroon (largest).

Module Technology

According to various filings for the installation submitted from 2019 through 2024, the Anson 1 solar facility is a 200 MW installation with the following equipment specifications:

  • Approximately 148,161 Astronergy CHSM6612P/HV 340W modules
  • Approximately 147,030 Astronergy CHSM6612P/HV 345W modules
  • Approximately 288,927 VSUN VS11N340-72PH 340W modules
  • Approximately 73,689 VSUN VSUN345-72P1-1 345W modules
  • Approximately 98,280 VSUN VSUN370-72MH 370W modules

Please note that these are self-reported module manufacturer and model specifications in permit filings, and may differ from the actual module numbers/manufacturer/model on site.

The tempered glass thickness for both the Astronergy and VSUN modules is 3.2 mm, much thicker than many modern module technologies at only 2 mm. Modules with these specs are frequently more robust during hailstorms [2]. However, in the case of catastrophic hail events (hail generally exceeding 40–50 mm in diameter), significant damage can still occur.

Outage and Production Impact

Table 1 shows all weather-related outages at the Anson site from May 2024 through December 2024. These outages are labeled as ice/cold weather events — normally assigned to winter events in Texas, but occasionally also assigned to extreme hail events that cause system outages. In total, there were approximately 8,697 unit-hours (summed across both units) of downtime likely associated with hail damage from the May 2024 storm, including partial and full outages, running intermittently from May through December as module replacement and remediation efforts were scheduled.

Table 1: Anson outages related to ice/cold weather
Both units (Unit 1 & Unit 2 track together); routine sub-day maintenance windows omitted
Period (local, CT)DurationCurtailedOutage typeERCOT reason code
May 2 – May 3129.7 days57 MW (57%)FORCEDCOLD WEATHER RELATED*
Aug 1 – Aug 25/3024–30 days61 MW (61%)FORCEDCOLD WEATHER RELATED*
Aug 25 – Aug 30 (Unit 1)5.6 days91 MW (91%)FORCEDCOLD WEATHER RELATED*
Sep 1 – Sep 3030.0 days61 MW (61%)FORCED EXTENSIONCOLD WEATHER RELATED*
Oct 1 – Nov 1949.6 days10 MW (10%)FORCEDCOLD WEATHER RELATED*
Nov 19 – Dec 3142.2 days50 MW (50%)FORCEDCOLD WEATHER RELATED*
Curtailment is against a 100 MW nameplate per unit, so the MW figure and the percentage are the same number. Source: outages for plant_id 11724. *Reason code as filed by the operator; timing points to the hailstorm as the real cause, not cold weather.

Figure 2 illustrates the unit-level impact of the storm on the Anson site. Original unit-level AC energy data is available at 15-minute intervals, but it is summed to daily rollups for easier viewing here. During this period, production for both units dropped by approximately 55% compared to average production during the same months in other years (2021, 2022, 2023, 2025).

Daily AC energy output, by unit
Anson 1 Unit 1 & Unit 2, MWh/day
Unit 1 Unit 2 Hailstorm, May 2, 2024 Hailstorm outage
View as table
Figure 2: Daily unit-level production following the May 2, 2024 hailstorm for the Anson 1 solar site. Post-storm outage attributed to weather stretches from May to the end of December 2024.

Estimating the Cost of the Storm

Using overall outage dates assigned to the "ice/cold weather" category and actual production during these periods, we can develop a basic methodology to estimate production losses as a result of the hail event. Note that this does not account for equipment losses or remediation costs. We are also attributing all lost production during the extended outage period of May to December to hail losses; there may be lost production due to other reasons that we are unaware of. Outage records for Anson between May–December 2024 do include some minor outages for maintenance reasons, but the majority of outages are attributed to hail damage.

To approximate the overall cost of the outage, we use solar satellite data to estimate the "ideal" unit-level production for all solar units experiencing an outage. This data, pulled from the National Laboratory of the Rockies' (formerly NREL) National Solar Radiation Database (NSRDB) [3], is fed into a PVWatts simulation to estimate production based on solar satellite irradiance [4]. Inputs include manually audited solar metadata available via the EnergyStream solar plant details endpoint. Excluding the weather-related outages, average production runs around 85% of idealized modeled production; during the outage event, actual production drops to approximately 37% of idealized production.

Actual vs. ideal daily production, both units combined
Anson 1, ERCOT-reported vs. PVWatts-modeled, MWh/day
Actual (ERCOT reported) Ideal (PVWatts estimate) Hailstorm, May 2, 2024 Hailstorm outage
View as table
Figure 3: Comparison of real production for the Anson 1 solar site against its "ideal" PVWatts-modeled production. The percent of ideal production drops from roughly 85% to 37% during the hail event and its subsequent outages.

Now that we know what the installation would have produced under ideal conditions, we can subtract actual production from idealized production during the listed hail outage period to estimate maximum lost energy:

total lost energy, MWh = max((PVWatts energy, MWh − actual energy, MWh), 0)

We set a clipped value of 0 when actual production is higher than ideal production, which can happen occasionally. Using this equation, we estimate a total lost energy of approximately 253 GWh across both Anson units. This value acts as a maximum threshold, as it assumes Anson would have produced at its "idealized" PVWatts-modeled level if not hit by the hailstorm.

Given that Anson produced about 85% of idealized production in the years without hail damage, we can also compare actual production against 85% of idealized production at each 15-minute interval:

lost energy, MWh = max((0.85 × PVWatts energy, MWh − actual energy, MWh), 0)

This gives a lower threshold of approximately 194 GWh.

Now that we have total energy lost, we can take this calculation further by estimating the total cost of the lost energy, using 15-minute settlement point pricing data associated with Anson. To do this, we simply multiply our 15-minute lost energy values with 15-minute settlement point price data, and then sum over the entire outage period to get the max total cost of lost production:

total loss, $ = Σ total lost energy, MWh × settlement point price

Using the equation above, the max total production loss due to the hailstorm was approximately $5.3 million. Given this assumes idealized energy, we can once again use the 85% adjustment, setting a lower threshold of $4.0 million. Given these numbers, we estimate the overall production losses at Anson due to the hailstorm were between $4.0 and $5.3 million.

Conclusions

This methodology shows how much a catastrophic hailstorm can cost in downtime for an impacted solar site. In the case of Anson 1, the May 2024 hailstorm led to 194–253 GWh of lost energy, or roughly $4.0–5.3 million at settlement point prices. These figures are modeled estimates, not metered losses: they rely on self-reported equipment details from permit filings, on outages coded by the grid operator as cold-weather events and attributed to hail based on timing, and on a modeled "ideal" production baseline. Actual losses will also depend on factors such as insurance terms, power purchase agreements, and hedges.

Implementing tracker hail stow systems, available from companies like Nextracker, Array Technologies, and FTC Solar, can mitigate damage to utility solar installations. By implementing hail stow during a storm, damages can be reduced significantly, and situations like Anson's can be heavily avoided. Furthermore, using hail stow trackers in high-risk areas can drop insurance premiums significantly.

This analysis relies on data available in the EnergyStream API. Datasets used are provided via the links below. If you're interested in learning more about the EnergyStream API, check out our API reference or request a demo. Free accounts get 100 queries a month on select endpoints, including weather risk profiles for 18,000 utility sites across the United States and site metadata details. Professional and Enterprise accounts get full access to production data for over 700 sites going back to 2014, as well as outage data for over 1,600 sites across Texas and California going back to 2020.

Citations
[1] Larry Ketchersid, "Proof of Recycling: Proving the Circular Economy", LinkedIn. linkedin.com/pulse/proof-recycling-proving-circular-economy-larry-ketchersid-dzgec
[2] Suprava Chakraborty, et al. "Analysis of the hail impacts on the performance of commercially available photovoltaic modules of varying front glass thickness", Renewable Energy, Feb. 2023. sciencedirect.com
[3] Sengupta, M., et al. "The National Solar Radiation Data Base (NSRDB)", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 89, 2018. doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2018.03.003
[4] Dobos, A. P. "PVWatts Version 5 Manual.", Sep. 2014. doi.org/10.2172/1158421
Data Endpoints
15-Minute Production, Anson Solar Center LLC (plant_id 11724)
Outages, Anson Solar Center LLC (plant_id 11724)
Site polygon: Site Boundaries, Anson Solar Center LLC (plant_id 11724)
Hail swath polygon: Hail Swaths, Anson Solar Center LLC (plant_id 11724)
PVWatts modeled ISO unit generation, Anson Solar Center LLC (plant_id 11724)
Settlement Point Prices, Anson Solar Center LLC (plant_id 11724)